The Witcher Author Andrza Sapkowski Has CLAIMED that the Controversial Netflix Fantasy Show Will Never Top His Novels. The show debut on the streaming platform in 2019 and was a big hit. Starring Henry Cavill as the titular Witcher Geralt of Rivia, The Show Also Sees Freeya Allen and Anya Chalotra in Supporting roles.
During Its Run, The Show Has Been Marked by Controversy, Allegedly Stemming from Cavill’s Dissatisphaction with the Direction the show was going, culminating in his deserture. He was replaced by liam hemsworth in the role of Geralt for The Witcher Season 4, and it is unclear how Much the show will continue past this point.
for RedditDuring an AMA SESSION BY PUBLISHERS ORBIT BOOKS, SAPKOWSKI Answered a Question About His Opinions on TV and Video Game Adaptations, and the Direction they’re Moving in. SAPKOWSKI STAUNCHLY DEFENDED The Written Word and Original Source Material, CLAIMING THAT ANY ADAPTATION LOES Something in the Process. Check Out His Comments Below:
I’ll put it this way: there’s the original and then there are adaptations. Regardless of the Quality of these adaptations, there are no dependencies or points of convergens between the literary original and its adaptation. The original stands alone, and every adaptation stands alone; You can’t translate words into images with lothout something, and there can’t get any connections. Moreover, adaptations are Mostly visualizations, whic means transforming writhten words into images, and there is no need to prove the superiority of the Word over images, it is obivious. The Written Word Always and Decidely Triumphs Over Images, and No Picture – Animated or Otherwise – Can Match the Power of the Word.
What this means for netflix’s the witcher
The Witcher Has Proven to be One of Netflix’s More DiviSIs adaptations, and It”s Clear to See Why. Though Early in the Show’s Run, IT DID A LARGELY ADAPTING OF ADAPTING SAPKOWSKI’S EPIC, SPRAWLING NOVELS, THERE IS STILL SO MUCH THAT THE SHOULD WAS UNABLE TO ADAPT EFFECTIVELY, AND THIS IS THE DISADVANTAGE THAT ADAPTATIONS HAVE TO RECRESHING THEK material.
While iT’s true that The Witcher isn’t an exact adaptation of the books, a frame-by-face remake could never work Because of the restrications that come with MAKING SHOWS. Nevertheless, there haen ben a strong deviation from what made of sapkowski’s books work so well, and this backs up the author’s CLAIMs that nothing canch the word.
Of Course, sapkowski is bound to have a degree of bias on this topic, gioven that is an author, but there is a truth to what he is saying. Written works containe the magic of imagination, and Everyone Who Reads a novel Imagines elements of it differently in their head. Watching an adaptation is experiencing a specific interpretation of that imagined experience.
This COULD ALSO BE SAPKOWSKI HAVING A SLIGHT Dig at the Direction Netflix has chosen to take The Witcherbut the essence of what he is saying does ring true. Adaptations Can Sometimes Work Really Well. Howver, i Never Quite the Same As Reading The Source Material, Because It Provides a Unique Experience for Everyone.
The Witcher
6/10
- Release Date
- December 20, 2019
- NETWORKS
- Netflix
- Showrunner
- Lauren Schmidt Hissrich
- Directors
- Stephen Surjik, Charlotte Brändström, Edward Basalgette, Loni Peristere, Louise Hooper, Bola Ogun, Alex Garcia Lopez, Gandja Monteiro, Sarah O’Gorman
-
-
Anya Chalotra
Yennefer of vengerberg
Source link
اترك تعليقاً